15
Dec
2007

Rich Lowry: Huckabee fine as GOP voter; as candidate, well …

National Review editor Rich Lowry is joining what threatens to become a parade of GOP flacks and hacks who wish all GOP voters were like Mike Huckabee—bone ignorant, Pavlovian Christians who can swallow the wildest swerves of logic with nary a hint of nausea—but are more than a bit panicked to find Huckabee threatening for the GOP presidential nomination and turning the primaries into a contest over who’s God bone is biggest. Here’s Lowry.

Huckabee has declared that he doesn’t believe in evolution. Even if there are many people in America who agree with him, his position would play into the image of Republicans as the anti-science party. This would tend to push away independents and upper-income Republicans. In short, Huckabee would take a strength of the GOP and, through overplaying it, make it a weakness.

In other words, pander but don’t empower. Get Huckabee aboard the bus but for God’s sake don’t let him drive.

Lowry, because he retains a modicum of self-consciousness, doesn’t directly abhor the role of religion in the Republican meltdown. Peggy Noonan, because she doesn’t, does. Lowry does delicately skirt the question of how the GOP acquired its “anti-science party” image, which is of course by way of ridiculing any science that respectively conflicts with popular religious beliefs, interferes with corporate prerogatives, or doesn’t involve blowing things up.

He also takes care to throw in some policy-related objections, observing that Huckabee, unlike his fellow candidates who wholeheartedly support the greatest national security debacle since the War of 1812, “not only has zero national-security credentials, he basically has no foreign-policy advisers either, as a New York Times Magazine piece this Sunday makes clear.” (How is it, by the way, that every pundit and reporter in the land read that story a week before publication?)

This is in contrast to, for instance, Rudy Giuliani, who boasts Norman “Nuke Iran” Podhoretz as his go-to guy on national security.

Huckabee’s record on taxes is another policy sore spot. The Bible-struck populist raised taxes in Arkansas for the shady purpose of helping poor people, and Lowry fears that his repentant gimmick—”a sales-tax scheme that allows him to say he supports eliminating the IRS, but is so wildly implausible that it would be a liability in a general election”—isn’t sufficient to overcome the fears of those same upper-income Republicans who detest Huckabee’s insistent religiosity, in this instance because they recognize, as Lowry says, that “the public tends to support Democratic proposals for bigger government, which Republicans counter by saying that the proposals will require higher taxes.”

But Republicans like Lowry have demonstrated time and again that they can stomach any policy perversion so long as it doesn’t cost elections, and Huckabee’s tax scheme is really no weirder than most Republican attempts to dodge reality on the subject. The real problem is that Huckabee represents an entire class of people whom Lowry is happy to goad to the polls every four years in support of whoever his chosen candidate might be, with whatever rhetorical gymnastics that requires, but with whom he otherwise wants nothing to do.

Tough break, Rich.

3 Responses to “Rich Lowry: Huckabee fine as GOP voter; as candidate, well …”

  1. 1
    Dave Miller Says:

    Although I agree in general with your article, if somebody said “Pavlonian Jews”, can you imagine all those charges of “anti-semitism”? And those same Christians(nutty ones I admit) are biggest supporters of Israel.

  2. 2
    Weldon Berger Says:

    Hi, Dave. Thanks for the comment.

    It’s shorthand for “Christians who respond positively to favorable mention of their religion regardless the circumstances or subtext.” Certainly one could apply the same label to Jews who react to similar support for Israel in similar fashion, and no doubt doing so would provoke, in Pavlovian fashion, charges of anti-semitism.

  3. 3
    BTC News: If It Says ‘News,’ It Must Be True » Blog Archive » Naddering nabobs, effete intellectual snobs trash Huckabee Says:

    [...] right’s jihad against Mike Huckabee today, following in the foosteps of his editor, Rich Lowry, and Ann Coulter at the malappropriately named Human [...]

Leave a Reply

BTC News: If It Says ‘News,’ It Must Be True is is proudly powered by Wordpress
Navigation Theme by GPS Gazette